How the catholic church sheltered nazi war criminals. Was the german lutheran church complicit in the nazi. How successfully did the nazis control the churches in germany. An agreement with the catholic church facing history and ourselves. Initially no more antisemitic than the norm, in the years before the great war he fell under the antisemitic influence of the volkish christian. There were approximately 45 million protestants and 22 million catholic christians in germany in 1933. While it is true that hitler deceived people across religious lines, including catholics, protestants, and even atheists, this is not the primary subject of this document. The reich church attempted to ban the use of the old testament in religious services as it was considered a jewish book. But the pope did not openly criticize the nazis until 1937. The church did not give the cause of death, saying only that pastor. Confessing church, german bekennende kirche, movement for revival within the german protestant churches that developed during the 1930s from their resistance to adolf hitler s attempt to make the churches an instrument of national socialist nazi propaganda and politics. Muller supported hitler and in 1933 he was given the title of reich bishop. But for the most part the church failed in its duty to resist. Religion nazi economic, social and racial policy wjec.
Opposition to nazi rule within germany did exist from 1933 to 1945. This book contains much important information that challenges a popularly embraced notion that christians did nothing in the face of the emerging and established nazi fascism in the 1930s and 40s. Catholic resistance to nazi germany was a component of german resistance to nazism and of resistance during world war ii. Nazi policies towards the catholic and protestant churches. At that point, wurm joined other prominent protestants in the anti nazi confessing church, such as dietrich bonhoeffer and martin niemoller, all of who were later imprisoned for their opposition to the nazis. That opposition took place at civilian, church and military levels. Opposition and resistance life in nazi germany 19331939 ocr. Hitlers propaganda minister, joseph goebbels, saw an insoluble. Many protestant pastors, led by martin niemoller, formed the confessional church in opposition to hitlers reich church. The church in nazi germany was subjected to as much pressure as any other organisation in germany. Nationalism was not as deeply embedded in the german catholic church, and the rabid anticatholicism of figures such as alfred rosenberg, a leading nazi ideologue during the nazi rise to power, raised early concerns among catholic leaders in germany and at the vatican. Dissenters and protestors against the nazi regime risked both their freedom and their lives. Its leaders, hans scholl, his sister sophie scholl, and professor kurt huber were arrested and executed in 1943 for the. Nazi germany the nazis and the church restistance to.
Meanwhile, bonhoeffers stand against the oppression of jews was hardening and he no longer spoke of them as inferior to christians. According to historian doris bergen, many german catholic clergy were initially suspicious of nazism. As a young man he grew increasingly bohemian and stopped attending church. Despite their opposition to the german christian movement, the confessing church did not object to most elements of nazism, and some people within the movement were nazi party members. Opposition to the nazi regime also arose among a very small number of german youth, some of whom resented mandatory membership in the hitler youth. Nazism, christianity and atheism a tippling philosopher. Popes pius xi 19221939 and pius xii 19391958 led the catholic church during the rise and fall of nazi germany. However, the consequences for those caught opposing hitler. The german christians were lead by ludwig muller who believed that any member of the church who had jewish ancestry should be sacked from the church. An agreement with the catholic church facing history and. A few openly opposed the nazis, while others saw themselves as neutral.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading preaching in hitler s shadow. The author was a dedicated catholic but at the end of his research he became convinced pope pius xii openly collaborated with the nazi s and turned a blind eye to the. Nevertheless, the church still retains many of the nazi symbols and icons, including a muscular aryan jesus, iron cross, statues of nazi stormtroopers, and a bust of adolf hitler. At the same time, they inherited a form of christianity that offered little opposition to nazism. The reich church aimed to be a new national church which advocated a form of nazi christianity. The flood of books and articles by the confessing church gives the misleading impression that the stand of the church toward the nazi state was one of resistance and opposition. Friedrich gustav emil martin niemoller was a german theologian and lutheran pastor. Some historians have charged that the catholic church helped the nazis in their persecution and genocide of the jewish people during the holocaust, or at least that it was not active enough in the 1930s and 40s in opposing nazism or the nazis final solution. What did each believe should be the relationship between protestant churches and the nazi government. Dean stroud has done a remarkable job translating and compiling sermons from courageous preachers who understood their times, recognized their fellow pastors defection from the gospel, and unapologetically proclaimed the truth no matter. Still others actively supported nazism, calling themselves storm troopers of jesus christ.
John cornwells 1999 book, hitlers pope, alleged that pius legitimised the. This policy was limited as the catholic population in the south did not follow the reichskirche and the nazis. The nazis made a major effort to coopt the christian protestant churches of germany. No other book at that time said, unequivocally, i was a nazi, and heres why. Around a third of germans were catholic in the 1930s, generally in southern germany. One of the most important books about the relationship of the catholic church with the nazis is a book written by john cornwell. Historians resist however a simple equation of nazi opposition to both judaism. Nazi attempts to supress the churches the reich church attempted to ban the use of the old testament in religious services as it was considered a jewish book. The bekennende kirchethe confessing churchemerged in opposition to. The holocaust and the catholic church the atlantic. This document has been created primarily as a response to accusations of catholic involvement in the nazi movment and regime. Catholic church collaboration with the nazis novels by.
Protestant churches and the nazi state facing history. How did christians and their churches in germany respond to the nazi regime. Opposition to the nazis existed but it was notoriously difficult. Recks christian faith underscored his hatred of the hitler regime. John frain, an academic, and onetime constituent of mine, provided a meticulous account in his book the cross and the third reich catholic resistance in the nazi era, for which i. Religion nazi economic, social and racial policy wjec gcse. The popes secret war against hitler basic books, 2015, he turns his meticulous attention to the whole matter of pope pius xii and what he really did or. Hitler saw christianity as a threat and a potential source of opposition to nazism because it emphasised peace. Learn about and revise what life was like in nazi germany between 1933 and 1939. Confessing church german protestant movement britannica. So many lies have gained currency about the relationship between nazism and the catholic church that it is high time to unveil undeniable historical facts.
The nazi propaganda minister, joseph goebbels, among the most aggressive antichurch nazis, wrote that there was an insoluble opposition between the christian and a heroicgerman world view. View the full nazi germany resource, with 30 freetoview. Author bartley unpacks a great trove of evidence to the contrary. In the midst of a fierce struggle for control of the churches, the pronazi german christian faction preached sermons, edited bibles, revised hymnbooks, altered liturgies, and changed the church calendar. The story recounted in this article up to this point has been, for the most part, a dismal one, but some christian churches and organizations outside of germany did evince vigorous opposition to the nazi. Martin niemoller, resolute foe of hitler the new york. The confessing church opposed the nazi regime, its activities, and specifically its interference. Despite this, there was a good deal of criticism of and resistance to the nazi regime between 1933 and 1939. Many writers, echoing klaus scholder, have concluded, there was no catholic resistance in germany, there were only catholics who resisted. Once, this was common knowledge and authors writing while the nazis were in power recognized this crucial fact.
Opposition, acquiescence and collaboration i by harry schnitker, ph. Opposition from the church nazi control of germany. German resistance to hitler the holocaust encyclopedia. Those who opposed the views of muller were called the confessing church. The german lutheran church and the rise of national socialism. In his youth he dabbled with occult thinking but never became a devotee. None of this opposition to the nazis was successful and it is difficult to know the true extent of it. As it happens, a recently published book by another austrian, the brilliant young scholar gerald steinacher, lays out in powerful, if lugubrious, detail how and why the catholic church, through its personnel, financing, and aid from institutions, committees, and priests, protected nazi war criminals. With burning concern nazi opposition from the church. One of the most interesting books to come across my desk in recent days is preaching in hitler s shadow.
Christian opposition to the hitler regime outside of germany. The church, the nazis, and the facts catholic answers. The nazis tried to control the churches with policies and bargaining. Meet the youngest person executed for defying the nazis history. In munich in 1942, university students formed the white rose resistance group. An expression of this was the nazi attempt to put church institutions under their control and subject them to nazi ideology. Luthers words are everywhere, the title of the exhibition highlighting how the nazis exploited martin luthers legacy during the third reich. However, those communists brave enough to engage in the resistance against the nazi regime faced a lonely, hopeless struggle, followed by the inevitable knock on the door from a member of the gestapo, detention in a concentration camp and, in most cases, execution. They created the concept of german christianity, which embraced nazi racist ideology and the subordination of the church the holy, universal church that contain. The german churches and the nazi state the holocaust. The church accused the regime of fundamental hostility to christ and his church. The disagreement between the two groups was focused on how much influence the nazi government should have over how they practiced their faith.
Niemoller was held in a concentration camp during the period 19371945. This was a failure for the nazis as the formation of the new church resulted in more opposition. How did nazis deal with the churches flashcards quizlet. Although the german catholic church had opposed the nazi party, the. According to historian paul bookbinder, while it is clear that many in the confessing church acted bravely, and some ended up in concentration camps, it is important to note what they didnt do. It instructed preachers to exclude any teaching from the old testament, as this was considered a. The german churches and the nazi state holocaust encyclopedia. For his opposition to the nazis state control of the churches, niemoller was imprisoned in. The book concentrates on the individuals and groups that resisted and opposed nazi rule, including the christian churches, industrial workers, youth groups and sections of the army, whose. A member of the church of jesus christ of latterday saints, he watched as the leader of his church joined the nazi party and the. Opposition, acquiescence and collaboration ii by harry schnitker, ph.
In 1933, the catholic church had viewed the nazis as a barrier to the spread of. Pius xii not only opposed hitler but plotted against him. The nazis also limited the influence of the catholic church by banning religious schools and religious youth groups, this meant that all children were now being indoctrinated in nazi schools and in the hitler youth, helping the nazis to control the churches in germany. Any perceived threat to hitler could not be tolerated and the churches of germany potentially presented the nazis with numerous threats. British journalist john cornwell, for example, referred to pope pius xii r. Video about how the nazis gained control of both the catholic and protestant church in germany and what happened to those who opposed his regime. Sermons of resistance in the third reich kindle edition by stroud, dean g download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. For germanys catholic church, the accession to absolute power of the nazis. Soon after he turned against the nazi regime, specifically in regards to education. The concordat effectively removed vatican opposition to the nazis, in exchange for. She may have been the first german, and certainly the first german woman, who tried to face her past with honesty. The role of the church during the nazi years was always, and remains however, a matter of much contention. During the 30s, nazi party members made up two thirds of the church attendance, where they also baptized their children. Protestant churches and the nazi state facing history and ourselves.
31 3 1115 1507 1011 1272 636 1109 809 1578 1554 1275 63 619 372 1509 86 458 1603 251 1231 1105 1095 970 1186 638 714 916 552 192 1152 177 547 1161 1344 544 1460 827 1140 181 812 543 1068 96